www.onlinerealityshow.com domain is for sale. If you are interested in buying, please contact us!

HUD display and navigation.

The X Factor is a rightwing Cinderella story that never comes true

16/10/2013 15:20

The rags-to-riches fairytale of success through hard work helps to keep a recession-damaged audience in its place.
Every autumn, to my great delight, The X Factor returns to our TV screens. I am the sort of fan who watches the show religiously, weeps along with the contestants and shouts obscenities when the judges take against my favourites. I love it despite myself.
It's self-evident that there's always been a Cinderella element to The X Factor: on one hand it's a singing competition, and on the other it's a rags-to-riches tale of ordinary people trying to make it in this cruel world; but never has that narrative been more dominant than the in the last couple of years, where it has virtually eclipsed the singing altogether. Last year's shows featured montages of contestants working in Asda (Jahmene Douglas) and living in a bedsit (James Arthur), each one consciously positing The X Factor as their only route out of the poverty and mundaneness of modern working-class life.
This shows no sign of abating: one of this year's contestants Relley Clarke has repeatedly referred to herself as "just a housekeeper" and done vox pops about how The X Factor is the only way she can achieve some kind of self-improvement. Another contestant, Hannah Barrett, began her second round of auditions by referring to her troubled past and vowing "I'm telling you now I'm not going back there" with a determination it was hard not to feel in your bones.
It's strange that something so obviously reflective of class politics is presented as totally apolitical. I've always thought that The X Factor represents a kind of rightwing wet dream; elevating neoliberal values such as individuality, competition and self-improvement over the socialist ideals of collectivism, community and common good. Indeed, the show straightforwardly appropriates working-class traditions which promote togetherness, such as working men's clubs and karaoke; and turns them into a competition for prosperity arbitrated by judges who are members of the super-rich.
Politicians frequently profess their love for The X Factor as a way of showcasing their common touch, but the only instance I can remember of one delving into the show's politics was in 2011, when Iain Duncan Smith – with trademark insight – blamed the "get rich quick" culture of the programme for the riots that summer. His musings led me to conclude that he is not a fan of the show; for if he were, he'd know there's nothing "get rich quick" about it. The X Factor is saturated with scenes of the judges eliciting promises of hard work and dedication from contestants. The overarching message seems to be a familiar one: if you just keep your head down, work hard and be very grateful, some glamorous millionaires might choose you above all others to join them in the lap of luxury.

Source: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2013/oct/11/x-factor-rightwing-cinderella-dream-relley-clark-2013